Jaynesian Consciousness

Why introspection isn’t innate... and what that changes.

The Architecture of Inner Voice

For most of human history your mind didn’t talk to itself. Julian Jaynes proposed that introspection, our “inner narrator,” is a cultural invention, born when symbolic language and social complexity reached a tipping point. Before that, decision-making felt like hearing commands from gods or ancestors. Introspection emerged when those external voices were internalised, giving rise to self-awareness.

How the Bicameral Mind Worked

Imagine walking into a new city without maps or street signs. Early humans navigated life by hearing “voices” commanding them, “Gather food,” “Flee danger,” “Build shelter,” and obeying without debate. Those commands came from social scripts learned through repetition. As languages grew richer, people began to recognise these voices as their own thoughts, and slowly the voice shifted from “Thou must” to “I will.”

Diagnostic Lens: Conscious Feature Audit

Consciousness has distinct features... spatialisation, narratisation, decentring and more. This lens measures how actively each feature shows up in your daily thinking, uncovering areas where your narrative simulation runs on autopilot.

Hey! I'm Chris.

I teach smart people how to feel human again.

[The Dirt] Newsletter offers brain-rewiring, metaphor-slinging, self-authorship tools for mental misfits (like you?).

This is not "self help" in any traditional sense. This is the recovery of your agency. Literally.

It's like therapy, but with less crying and more “Oh… that explains everything!”

Subscribe for Weekly Insights into Self-Authorship

This list is small and personal.
Unsubscribe anytime, and your email vanishes like it was never here.
(Yes, really.)
Use your real email.
That’s the one I’m writing to.

Features of Consciousness Explained

Spatialisation – your ability to construct an internal arena where experiences, thoughts and images have position and distance.
Excerption – the mind’s selective spotlight, focusing on one element while dimming others.
Analogue ‘I’ – the mental avatar that moves through your inner space, representing your agency.
Metaphor ‘Me’ – the self as described by metaphor, the bridge between raw sensation and personal identity.
Narratisation – the weaving of events into a coherent story, linking past, present and future.
Conciliation – the process of folding new information into your existing narrative without breaking the storyline.
Concentration and Suppression – the twin gates that decide which thoughts and feelings get amplified, and which are silenced.
Decentring – stepping outside your own perspective to observe yourself as another might see you.
Interiority Scaffolding – the symbolic frameworks (rituals, language patterns, mental models) that support complex reflection.
Self-reflexivity – the recursive awareness that you are aware, enabling you to monitor and adjust your own thinking.

A Story of Awakening

Ethan always felt torn between two urges, one part of him screaming “Stay silent,” another urging “Speak up.” He journalled both as separate voices until he realised they were old cultural scripts: “Silence equals safety” and “Voice equals risk.” When he rewrote them together in one narrative, “My voice and my silence both serve my choices,” the conflict eased. He found he could choose when to speak without feeling divided.

A Mini-Workshop: Noticing Your Narrator

Use these prompts in real moments, when you hesitate, celebrate or wrestle with a choice:

Observe one inner command you hear today (“Don’t ask that question,” “Push harder,” “Play it safe”).
Map its origin: Did it come from a parent’s advice, a mentor’s mantra or a cultural maxim?
Question its validity: “Does obeying this serve my present goals, or is it an echo from the past?”
Re-author the script: Write a new internal command that aligns with your values (for example, “I ask bold questions” instead of “Stay silent”).
Reflect briefly in your journal on how choosing your own voice changed the outcome.

By spotting the inherited narrator, you reclaim authorship over your own mind.

Collaborative Reflection: Simulation Exploration

Jaynes and McVeigh list core features of consciousness (spatialisation, narratisation, decentring, etc.). Rate your own awareness of each on a 1–5 scale and note one real example when each feature was active or absent in your thinking.

Pair up and share your audit scores. Ask each other targeted questions (“When did you last narratise a decision?” “How often do you decentre in conflict?”). Brainstorm two practices to strengthen your lowest-scoring feature and commit to testing one this week.

Next Steps

Explore the Metaphorical Self strategy to map the deeper frames that fuel your inner dialogue.
Get The Dirt for weekly-ish rambles about how this mind stuff plays out in real life.